Are you using an insurance broker or one of those self service ones? If you're using a broker, it's their job to find the best rate and coverage for you. But I suspect they are on some kind of program with certain underwriting companies. So go to another broker and see if you get a different rate and ask who the underwriting company is. I think the usual suspects are Brown, Johnston Meier, HUB, and some other folks. Also, is this renter's insurance? I don't see any property (premise) listed. Ask about the separate caps / sub limits for electronics, jewelry, ID papers, tools, and identify theft (could be a perk).