What's new
  • Please do not post any links until you have 3 posts as they will automatically be rejected to prevent SPAM. Many words are also blocked due to being used in SPAM Messages. Thanks!

Valve Portal 2 Game Review

Status
Not open for further replies.

FiXT

Hall of Fame
Joined
Apr 11, 2008
Messages
3,265
Location
GVRD
Portal was one of 2007’s greatest surprises. Not only did it offer a ground-breaking and mind-blowing experience, it did so in style, offering a script still quoted (some might say excessively) to this day and one of the most memorable characters this side of the 16-bit era. Rather than deliver an incremental sequel, ala Left4Dead 2, Valve has spent the last four years building, refining, and polishing their follow-up to this amazing title.

Portal 2 picks up hundreds of years after the events of the first. Chell awakens from a medically-induced hibernation to find herself in the remains of what appears to be an old, decrepit hotel room (not terribly dissimilar to many of the hotels I’ve stayed at...). You’re soon greeted by the jovial, and especially British, Wheatley. This robotic orb, who watches over the facility's test subjects, explains that the facility is in danger and he wants to help you escape...in the most comical way possible: transporting your shipping container-style room through the collapsing facility. He finally “docks” (crashes) it into a wall, all the while apologizing for his deficiencies with his usual hilarious British charm. Wheatley, like GLaDOS before him, is an outstandingly well-written character brought to life with a brilliant performance by Stephen Merchant.

robot-thumb.jpg


Wheatley will escort you through the first hour or so of the game as you explore the remains of the facility and regroup with old friends. It is this beginning that marks one of the finest introductions to a game I’ve ever played. The opening hour is so perfectly paced and constructed, I was worried if Valve would be able to maintain the quality throughout the entire 10+ hour adventure. And fortunately, they mostly do.

In retrospect, the amount of diversity Portal derived from its single core mechanic is amazing --using a pair of portals for instant travel--which makes it all the more impressive how much Valve has managed to add for the sequel. While you’ll still make use of Newton's laws and companion cubes, you’ll now find yourself being introduced to new concepts on a regular basis, such as the prism cube, which is often used to reflect a single laserbeam through multiple objects; with the help of portals of course.

Like with the laser, you’ll find yourself manipulating and funneling different kinds of substances through the portals, such as light-based walkways, tractor beams, and some very unique liquids. These liquids come in three varieties and enable a special ability when stepped on. Blue allows Chell to jump high, orange to run fast, and any surface adorned in white will allow her to plant a Portal, regardless of whether the surface itself is portal resistant. All three play a factor through much of the game’s second act, delivering some of the game’s more devious puzzles.

goo1-thumb.jpg


Oh yes, the puzzles--the crux of Portal’s gameplay. Luckily, the game covers the basics from Portal 1 quickly before launching into puzzles with much more involved -but never unwieldy- mechanics. To offer any specific examples would be to ruin the fun, but I can say that the puzzles offer a similar level of difficulty as those in the first, and were almost never frustrating. Regardless of how punishing some of them may appear, they’re almost always fair, and make sense within the game’s logic. However, there was a time or two when I found myself stuck for longer than I care to admit, only to discover an easily overlooked wall where I was supposed to attach a portal. And there was one specific instance involving a pipe-filled room and a HORRIBLY steep slope that was a chore simply to navigate. Minor issues aside, the puzzles are creative, fun, and almost entirely frustration-free.

The visuals, art design in particular, are a significant advancement from the original--which already looked great itself. The bulky elevators have been replaced with a modern, streamlined appearance and the facility as a whole has been given a fantastic layer of polish. You’ll now watch as test chambers are constructed before your very eyes, which is simply a joy to watch. Though perhaps most worthy of praise are the spectacular looking liquids. And I don’t just mean in the typical “pretty water effects” kind of way. These liquid gels actually look and behave much as you would expect in real-life, with blobs assimilating together when close, but breaking apart when in free-fall. It’s a fantastic effect that actually gives them substance and volume, in stark contrast to the flat water effects of many games.

Sound too has been improved, with music now used much more frequently. The game actually dynamically creates these tracks to correspond to the action you’re performing. It’s a neat touch and helps accentuate your actions.

gladdos-thumb.jpg


Of course, Portal became famous for much more than just its gameplay conceit. It also featured a memorable antagonist and an engrossing narrative, largely thanks to the game’s very mysterious setting. And this is perhaps the one area where Portal 2 falters slightly by comparison. Though the characters are still strong--Wheatley may actually be my new favorite--the story simply isn’t as engaging, due at least in part to the fact that the mystery of the facility and your role within it were largely resolved with the first game. Sure, there are still some mysteries to be solved, complete with a twist or two, but it’s hard to care as much about the story when it seems so familiar.

Speaking of the twists--don’t worry, no spoilers--I found them a bit disappointing because of their effect on the characters. One of the twists, in particular, is so silly, that it actually undermines the sense of immersion the series so greatly captures. The ending, as well, lacks the emotional punch of the original, partially due to the same twist even if it’s still very satisfactory.

One final criticism is the amount of loading screens. Because one pops up after every testing area, you’ll be seeing them a lot, particularly toward the beginning of the game. Fortunately, the load times themselves aren’t bad, but they still break-up the game’s otherwise perfect flow.

Despite these minor problems, Portal 2, like with the original is one of the best games I’ve ever played. Though it doesn’t quite capture the sense of mystery or the initial “holy crap, that was amazing!” reaction of its benchmark predecessor, it exceeds it almost every other area. The grander scope, new portal mechanics, fantastic puzzle design, and hilarious script more than make up for these deficiencies which, I can’t stress enough, are only evident by way of comparison. And though the game more than doubles the length of its predecessor, it seems to pass almost as fast--a true testament to the game’s design.

Whereas Portal 1 engaged my mind, Portal 2's single player mode captured my heart. It is a fantastic sequel to a benchmark game and serves as the most effective argument against the annualization trend burdening many popular series. I *companion cube* Portal 2. Skip to the next page for our multiplayer review.

<iframe title="YouTube video player" width="640" height="390" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/2B6Htv89JPQ" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>​



The Verdict: Portal 2 Single-Player

As brilliant as the British are funny. A near perfect follow-up to 2007's classic.
review_star_full.png
review_star_full.png
review_star_full.png
review_star_full.png
review_star_full.png
5/5​
 
Last edited by a moderator:

FiXT

Hall of Fame
Joined
Apr 11, 2008
Messages
3,265
Location
GVRD
Portal 2 Multiplayer

Not simply content to release a full-length single-player campaign, Valve went the extra mile and developed a dedicated cooperative mode. Not only are the puzzles all original, complete with elements not in the single-player campaign, but you also play as two new protagonists: Atlas and P-body, who are the unfortunate subjects of GLaDOS’s latest tests.

Two brains are better than one, right? To compensate, the cooperative campaign has an added emphasis on stumping you. And not only are the puzzles intentionally more devious, they’re also made tougher by the amount of options available, due in part to each of you having a pair of portals to work with. Unlike many cooperative games, teamwork is an undeniable must. Luckily, there is little more rewarding than working together to discover the solution.

coop-thumb.jpg


If you are embracing Valve's move to the console, Portal 2 multiplayer is playable both online or locally via split-screen, while the PC version is available online and via LAN, with both the PC and PS3 available for cross platform play via Steam.

While playing on the same TV might be preferred, due to the heavy amounts of communication involved, Valve has included several options for online players to help make up for these deficiencies, such as being able to place markers to show your partner where to plant a portal, using pre-set actions, automated count-down timer to coordinate activities, and you’ll even have the option to temporarily play in split-screen in order to fully understand what your partner is doing. Impressively, despite there being twice the amount of portals, cooperative runs nearly as smooth as the single-player portion, even during a split-screen session

Besides the visuals, almost every aspect of co-op feels like a natural extension of the main story, including the fantastic humor. In fact, GLaDOS is as offensive as ever, pulling no punches when it comes to assessing you and your teammate’s performance. The sharp humor actually serves as a nice mental-break between some of the more grueling challenges.

coop2-thumb.jpg


Altogether, not only has Valve followed-up the original game with a single-player of equal caliber, but they managed to do the same for the cooperative mode too. Serving as a great compliment to the main story, the cooperative mode offers about as much content, only now it can be enjoyed with a friend too. Seriously, this is one of the best designed cooperative experience I’ve played, with the amount of care having went into it apparent the entire adventure. It’s worth making at least one friend for.


The Verdict: Portal 2 Multiplayer

An outstanding cooperative experience that's well worth your while
review_star_full.png
review_star_full.png
review_star_full.png
review_star_full.png
review_star_full.png
5/5​

This review was based on the Playstation 3 version of the game.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Top