You guys are crazy.
Phaneuf is much better than White, they cannot be compared. Phaneuf is a larger player with a better shot who thinks offensively. Ian White is a small player with great heart who thinks neutral and just began to think a little on the offensive side. Hagman was the Leaf's biggest loss on this trade, but even so it's not a devestating change. Mayers and Stajan are both replaceable players, nothing special. The Leafs got the better deal on this trade by sending away a few bodies that weren't producing enough for the team.
As others have said, Kabby and Phaneuf will greatly improve the powerplay. McCabe 2.0? I'm very happy to have a new "McCabe", just younger and bigger.
As for Blake & Toskala for J.S., there's nothing wrong with this trade at all. Blake was clearly having trouble being productive at all here in Toronto and Toskala is performed way too inconsistent to keep throwing chances at him. J.S. has been taught by Allure and now he can help Gustavsson until he is ready to take over in a year or two.
The young players have a huge chance to prove themselves now, can't wait to see Stahlberg again.
Great day for Leaf fans.